SMALL BATCH ICE CREAM…
BIG 90’s FUN!
WHY CHOOSE TOTALLY ICE CREAM?
ALL of our ice creams are made in-shop.
We are a family-owned ice cream shop specializing in Super Premium Homemade Ice Cream. We strongly believe that Premium Ice Cream should be a nostalgic and FUN experience for all ages!
We started as a Florida company based out of Pinellas County where most of the year it is hot, and even when it is not?
Totally Ice Cream was ALWAYS IN THE 90’s!
We are still lost in the 90’s - just sitting on top of the Cumberland Plateau in Spencer, TN outside of Fall Creek Falls State Park!
ICE CREAM FLAVORS
Flavors in stock will change routinely
This is a comprehensive list of every flavor we have ever made!
PREMIUM ICE CREAM
Totally Chocolate (GF)
Totally Vanilla (GF)
Strawberry Cheesecake
Coffee Crunch (GF)
Totally Coconut (GF)
Oreo Cookie
Orange Chocolate (GF)
American Air
Banana Pudding
Chocolate Banana Cream (GF)
Mint Chocolate Flake (GF)
Bubble Gum (GF)
Sweetie Pie Pie
Totally Super Man (GF)
Blue Moon (GF)
PB Cream Flake (GF)
Super Lemon (GF)
Pumpkin Pie Custard
Apple Pie
Sweet Corn (GF)
Candy Cane Kisses (GF)
Egg Nog (GF)
Golden Oreo
Chocolate Covered Cherry (GF)
Caramel Latte (GF)
Lemon Blueberry Cookie “The LBC”
Skittles (GF)
Cookie Cream (GF)
Vanilla Chocolate Flake (GF)
Black Raspberry Brownie
Half Baked Cookie Dough
German Chocolate (GF)
Chocolate Caramel Brownie
Mango Madness (GF)
DAIRY-FREE
Pineapple Coconut (GF)
Lemon Raspberry
Orveo
Peanut Butter Brownie
Cherry Ripe (GF)
Bananutella (GF)
Mango Ice (GF)
Cherry Ice (GF)
Lemon Ice (GF)
Mangonada (GF)
ALCOHOL-INFUSED (21+)
Vegan Pina Colada (GF)
Mimosa (GF)
French Toast (GF)
Fireball! (GF)
Margarita Cream (GF)
Rum Raisin (GF)
Strawberry Daquiri (GF)
Cousin Eddie’s Egg Nog (GF)
Candy Cane (GF)
White Chocolate Pinot Grigio (GF)
Merlot (GF)
White Russian (GF)
Peaches & Cream (GF)
Mystic Slide (GF)
Red Sangria (GF)
ROLLED ICE CREAM
Cookies & Cream
Gimme S’More
Bubble Gummy (GF)
Strawberry Shortcake
Peanut Butter Cup (GF)
Caramel Apple (GF)
My Nutty Valentine (GF)
Triple Chocolate (GF)
Peaches & Cream
The 90’s.
Many memories.
NO EVIDENCE.
-Random Person on the Internet
